In the fast-paced realm of geopolitical commentary, few narratives capture public interest quite like the ongoing tensions between Israel and Iran. In a recent segment featuring former Pentagon official Dan Caldwell on Tucker Carlson’s platform, insights were shared regarding the potential ramifications of political decisions, especially those by influential figures like Senator Ted Cruz. However, in the world of information and analysis, it is crucial to dissect claims and assertions meticulously to separate fact from speculation. This blog post will delve into the key points raised in Caldwell’s discussion, fact-checking the predictions made about the conflict’s future and examining their validity against established geopolitical contexts. Join us as we navigate through the complexities surrounding this critical issue.

Find a fact check of this transcript on CheckForFacts

Transcript:

[00:00:00,000]: So it seems likely the U S government will participate in offensive strikes on Iran’s nuclear facilities

[00:00:06,659]: If that happens what next

[00:00:08,920]: How does Iran respond

[00:00:10,899]: Can airstrikes alone end the nuclear program

[00:00:14,800]: And what happens to the rest of the countries in the region and Iran’s allies

[00:00:19,979]: Do they get involved

[00:00:20,920]: There’s no better person to talk this through with than former Pentagon official Dan Caldwell who joins us now

[00:00:47,959]: As we sit here right now and I hope you’ll correct me if you think this is this impression is wrong but I think the general view among people who are watching what’s happening in Iran is that there will be some kind of U S strike

[00:01:02,799]: I’m not this is I’m getting this from what I’m reading in the popular press

[00:01:06,379]: There will be some kind of strike on Iran by the U S military against an enrichment site the famous subterranean enrichment site with some kind of conventional large conventional bunker buster weapon

[00:01:21,540]: That has not happened

[00:01:22,940]: Of course we don’t know that’s going to happen

[00:01:24,279]: We don’t know anything

[00:01:26,959]: But let’s just assume that does happen

[00:01:31,000]: What happens next

[00:01:33,019]: Well let me just say if it does happen I hope all my predictions are dead wrong

[00:01:38,699]: Me too

[00:01:39,419]: Thank you for saying that

[00:01:40,860]: That means dead Americans

[00:01:42,680]: And you know I won’t say who I was talking to somebody who I guess you could describe as a neoconservative

[00:01:48,779]: And you know I said I hope if this happens you’re making fun of me and calling me an idiot

[00:01:54,099]: Me too

[00:01:54,779]: I totally

[00:01:55,720]: I really mean that because there’s guys who are just like me 15 20 years ago that are going to be in the middle of this fight either they’re going to be on some of these bases that will likely come under attack they’re going to be part of air crews they’re going to be on some of these ships

[00:02:08,639]: I really hope that all the confident predictions play out and I’d love to be wrong

[00:02:12,919]: Can I ask you this

[00:02:13,740]: How are those guys since you’ve been one of those guys how are those guys feeling right now

[00:02:17,979]: You know are they getting news

[00:02:20,220]: Are they on social media

[00:02:21,139]: Are they aware of what people in the US are saying about the likelihood of this

[00:02:24,940]: I think that a lot of them are

[00:02:27,979]: I have spoken to a few that are still in the service and the ones that I talk to are either senior listed or more senior officers

[00:02:36,740]: So they’ve been around for 15 20 some cases 25 years at the tail end of their careers

[00:02:42,460]: And honestly a lot of those guys are tired

[00:02:45,979]: And these were guys 20 years ago that the one thing they wanted was to get in the fight

[00:02:51,919]: They wanted to go to Iraq

[00:02:52,979]: They wanted to go to Afghanistan

[00:02:54,619]: Some of them are on their seventh eighth deployments either to the region or to Europe or somewhere else

[00:03:04,360]: And they’re worn out

[00:03:05,860]: And they also see that the military has really continued to be overstretched despite the fact that the Iraq and Afghanistan wars have wound down

[00:03:14,119]: And remember we still have thousands of troops in Iraq and Syria

[00:03:18,679]: Thankfully the Trump administration prior to this appears to have started a retrograde a withdrawal from Syria

[00:03:24,559]: Hopefully we go to zero there

[00:03:26,440]: So we still have a lot of troops there

[00:03:29,100]: And a lot of them just feel like we’ve been doing this for so long and there’s so many things we have to do to fix the military to fix the culture something the DOD is really trying to prioritize

[00:03:41,520]: We need to reform our army

[00:03:43,500]: Secretary Dan Driscoll is starting this major army reform effort that I think is important

[00:03:49,059]: And another war will distract away from that will take resources away from that

[00:03:53,259]: There’s a huge problem right now with standard of living within the United States military

[00:03:59,479]: A lot of barracks are falling apart

[00:04:02,940]: You had the Navy Secretary John Fallon and credit to him he went out to Guam and saw the decrepit state of the barracks for I believe the Marines out there

[00:04:12,020]: And he ordered them shut down

[00:04:13,740]: And they were so bad

[00:04:15,339]: So another war that not only puts more lives in danger and requires more deployments to that region after 20 years of continuous deployment sometimes the last minute again it takes resources away from things we need to do

[00:04:31,059]: And I think a lot of folks are really worried about that as well

[00:04:34,480]: If you’re on a ship in the region right now and you think there could be offensive military action by the U S military and you’re at some level of the chain you’re part of it are you nervous

[00:04:48,299]: I mean when I was in the Marine Corps even though we are an amphibious branch I never served on a ship before I flew over to Iraq I didn’t go over on a boat float

[00:05:00,299]: I mean from what it’s been described to me you’re in a metal container

[00:05:06,500]: I used to talk a lot of trash about the Navy but understanding what it’s like to live on a ship six months at a time and especially when you get extended over and over again I’d rather do multiple deployments to Iraq

[00:05:17,839]: I just like to say that

[00:05:19,760]: But it’s very isolating

[00:05:21,760]: It’s very scary because you sometimes feel like you don’t have control and that events are out of your hands in a way that’s maybe not the same for somebody who’s serving in the infantry or you’re an individual pilot

[00:05:35,359]: You don’t know where to run literally

[00:05:36,779]: Yes

[00:05:37,279]: Yeah it’s terrifying

[00:05:39,200]: And as been publicly reported we had some very very close calls in the recent fight against the Houthis

[00:05:46,459]: There was some anti ship missiles

[00:05:50,279]: We have a very effective ballistic missile defense and anti missile defense on these but one of the reasons why one of those F 18s fell off the Harry S S

[00:06:02,980]: Truman was because it had to do some aggressive maneuvers to potentially avoid a Houthi anti ship missile and thankfully it didn’t hit

[00:06:10,959]: But imagine being one of the 6 000 sailors and Marines on that ship in that moment

[00:06:17,880]: And it’s terrifying

[00:06:19,359]: It can be absolutely terrifying

[00:06:20,820]: It is terrifying

[00:06:21,760]: I’m sorry to interrupt you

[00:06:23,359]: No I was thinking that this morning what would it be like to be one of those guys just waiting for something to happen and knowing it could be the end

[00:06:29,440]: Nothing but respect for the United States Navy

[00:06:31,519]: I totally agree

[00:06:33,339]: So you were saying and I just wanted to add my voice and be in agreement I really hope to be wrong in every one of my predictions

[00:06:40,160]: I hope to laugh at myself and apologize to everyone for being hysterical

[00:06:43,980]: I really hope that I can do that

[00:06:46,059]: And I know you feel the same way

[00:06:47,619]: So with that caveat what do you think is likely to happen if a strike of the nature that I described happens

[00:06:52,700]: Well I think the event to look back to that could show us what could happen is what happened after the Soleimani strike

[00:07:03,559]: And it’s not a perfect comparison because it’s pretty clear the Iranians telegraphed to us that they were going to do that

[00:07:11,339]: We had some back channel communications most likely

[00:07:14,279]: And so we knew it was coming

[00:07:16,279]: And so our troops on Al Asad Air Base where I served and actually interestingly where the vice president served as well too many years ago were able to get to shelters and to get out of places that were very exposed

[00:07:29,140]: And Iran launched a salvo of ballistic missiles at Al Asad Air Base

[00:07:34,119]: But even then Which is where

[00:07:35,940]: Al Asad Air Base is in Western Iraq

[00:07:38,399]: It’s in Al Anbar province

[00:07:40,260]: It’s in Al right

[00:07:41,880]: And one thing to note about that base is that we do a lot of joint training with the Iraqi Army

[00:07:49,679]: And the Iraqi Army is part of the same government that has another security force called the Popular Mobilization Force which is a group of militias that are loyal to Iran

[00:08:02,260]: They were funded initially supported and trained by Quds Force led by Soleimani at the time

[00:08:08,720]: And so we are at that base training allies of the people that are likely going to be trying to kill us in this war

[00:08:15,660]: So that’s important to remember

[00:08:17,559]: And that I think can lead you to understand That is still the case

[00:08:23,160]: Absolutely

[00:08:23,920]: Our main mission in Iraq right now is to support the Iraqi security forces which includes the Popular Mobilization Forces which consists of Iran allied militia groups

[00:08:36,780]: This is so bonkers

[00:08:38,460]: It is the most convoluted mission I think on the face of the earth right now

[00:08:43,159]: Is that a mission

[00:08:43,739]: That seems like A suicide pack

[00:08:46,260]: Kind of

[00:08:46,780]: Kind of

[00:08:47,500]: It seems like putting guys in jeopardy for What’s the purpose exactly

[00:08:51,960]: We’re literally propping up an ally of Iran and we’re subsidizing an ally of Iran

[00:08:56,919]: And some will argue it’s like well we need these troops in Al Asad and we need them in parts of Baghdad still and other parts of the country to check Iran

[00:09:06,979]: But a small number of troops is not meaningfully influencing the Iraqi government and it’s not providing a meaningful check on Iranian influence

[00:09:17,840]: They’re just easy targets that allow the Iranians to bleed us cheaply

[00:09:24,659]: So without divulging anything I mean I know that you won’t during the course of this conversation say anything that is privileged or legally confidential secret

[00:09:32,520]: But as far as you know they’re there today

[00:09:35,099]: Those American troops are still in Iraq

[00:09:37,219]: As far as I know yes

[00:09:38,020]: Still surrounded by Iranian proxies

[00:09:39,960]: Yes

[00:09:41,179]: Yes

[00:09:41,700]: I would still have concerns about a strike a direct military intervention in Iran were those troops not there

[00:09:51,619]: But the risks would be substantially lower if we didn’t have troops in Iraq and Syria

[00:10:12,479]: Governments are the highest bidder

[00:10:14,059]: Just last week for example a new leak caused a 364 000 person leak

[00:10:20,700]: That means 364 000 people had their private information go public

[00:10:25,619]: That’s a massive invasion of privacy at scale really

[00:10:30,780]: So we trust ExpressVPN to protect us from falling victim to these schemes

[00:10:34,760]: ExpressVPN is an app that reroutes 100 of your online traffic through secure encrypted servers and that prevents data brokers or anyone else from seeing what you’re doing and stealing your private information and reselling it

[00:10:45,380]: That means what you do on your computer everything you click on everything you watch every friend you make on social media will be private as it should be

[00:10:53,820]: ExpressVPN also hides your IP address

[00:10:55,679]: That’s the data number that brokers use to track your behavior and then sell it

[00:11:01,859]: So right now you can get an extra four months for free when you use this show’s link

[00:11:05,380]: Scan the QR code on the screen go to expressvpn com

[00:11:08,799]: slash Tucker and get four extra months of ExpressVPN expressvpn com

[00:11:14,000]: slash Tucker

[00:11:17,979]: Man can I just say something really cynical

[00:11:20,559]: It’d be pretty easy to draw us in to a ground war against or a full scale regime change effort against Iran by attacking those troops no matter who you are

[00:11:30,179]: I’ve said it publicly prior to being a DOD

[00:11:35,299]: In a lot of ways those troops in Iraq and Syria were a tripwire to a larger war

[00:11:44,940]: Especially after the defeat of ISIS Caliphate and you can argue whether or not they should have been put back in Iraq and Syria to begin with but especially after the ISIS Caliphate they should not have been there

[00:11:54,979]: There were many crimes in the first Trump administration but one of the greatest crimes in the first Trump administration was an active effort by President Trump’s own political appointees in some cases and elements of the military to undermine his stated preference to withdraw particularly from Syria

[00:12:15,919]: Let’s not forget you had the president’s special representative I believe for Syria this guy Jim Jeffrey who after he left the administration ran around Washington D C bragging about lying to the president about the number of troops in Syria so that he would be less likely to withdraw them

[00:12:38,719]: That’s not a crime

[00:12:39,419]: I think that’s a crime

[00:12:40,460]: It should be

[00:12:41,479]: It absolutely should be

[00:12:42,799]: And it’s disgraceful

[00:12:44,380]: Subverting the civilian leadership of the military is not a crime

[00:12:46,700]: I think it is

[00:12:48,099]: Absolutely is

[00:12:48,979]: And it was completely outrageous

[00:12:52,619]: And as a result I think there’s a direct line between that and last year when you had three army reservists killed at Tower 22 in Jordan by a drone

[00:13:08,000]: Tower 22 in Jordan is directly in support of it exists to support a base in Syria

[00:13:13,739]: And had Jim Jeffrey and others not undermined President Trump those three reservists would likely still be alive today

[00:13:20,900]: Why is it called Tower 22

[00:13:23,000]: Honestly I’m not entirely sure

[00:13:25,159]: But it is a U S military installation of some kind in Jordan

[00:13:27,619]: Yes

[00:13:27,900]: Whose purpose is to support the U S military installation that is in Syria but shouldn’t be

[00:13:32,099]: It’s literally right across the border

[00:13:33,919]: And that installation in Syria is called TANF

[00:13:37,859]: And again none of this has all been reported public info

[00:13:42,880]: That was originally established to train anti Assad fighters to basically effectively retrain them to fight ISIS

[00:13:53,479]: And so then that mission morphed into a counter Iran mission where they wanted to keep American troops there and the proxies there

[00:14:04,679]: So Iran wouldn’t have a line of communication or basically an ability to move forces from Iran through Iraq to Syria

[00:14:13,400]: So that was justification

[00:14:15,179]: But then things changed in northern Syria

[00:14:17,859]: The Syrian army started collaborating more with the Kurds

[00:14:19,940]: So they got a line of communication

[00:14:22,020]: And so then it ran out another mission

[00:14:23,460]: And then it became airspace control

[00:14:26,140]: And by the time it was you got to January 2020 I believe it’s January February 2024 when this incident happened the Biden administration it was reported when people asked about the Syria policy Biden admin officials would just laugh because we had none

[00:14:44,960]: So they were sitting there for no reason other than this belief is that you can never withdraw or retrench from anywhere because it’s surrender

[00:14:54,059]: Well and the irony is of course that elements of ISIS now run Syria

[00:14:56,919]: And we’re cool with that for some reason

[00:14:59,340]: Yeah I mean at the end of the day Jelani was created an American prison

[00:15:05,400]: Now I will say I think it is good

[00:15:09,080]: We’re trying to remove sanctions on Syria

[00:15:11,440]: I totally agree

[00:15:13,140]: Because you know sanctions only hurt the average person in Syria

[00:15:18,320]: I’m glad we’re pursuing that

[00:15:19,840]: I’m glad we’re trying to pursue some type of diplomatic course there

[00:15:22,580]: But let’s be honest who won that war

[00:15:24,659]: Al Qaeda won the war

[00:15:25,840]: Well that’s the point

[00:15:26,799]: Look I’m rooting for Jelani

[00:15:28,099]: I want him to become you know a wise leader who makes the region more stable and peaceful

[00:15:33,619]: And I want everyone to succeed

[00:15:36,520]: But as long as we’re framing everything in moral terms this just shows the true bankruptcy of the program

[00:15:43,780]: Yeah that we replaced Assad with Al Qaeda

[00:15:49,580]: Yeah you know I guess the one thing they have in common is you both begin with A first

[00:15:53,880]: But the one thing they don’t have in common is only one of them is responsible for 9 11

[00:15:58,760]: So I think I’m pretty pro Assad if that’s the choice

[00:16:01,539]: I mean yeah Assad definitely was incredibly nasty and awful

[00:16:06,760]: But since you bring up 9 11 who did we cooperate with after 9 11

[00:16:10,719]: We sent prisoners to Assad to help interrogate

[00:16:15,940]: And ultimately we had a shared interest in stopping Al Qaeda

[00:16:21,900]: So we cooperated with Assad early on terror

[00:16:24,400]: I know

[00:16:25,020]: So if you if you were to frame your foreign policy around your own interests or even around your own grievances like it’s fair to be mad about 9 11

[00:16:32,219]: Yeah those people died 3000

[00:16:34,520]: Then you would be you would definitely not be happy that the guy who helped you after 9 11 was overthrown in favor of the people who did 9 11

[00:16:42,320]: Like from an American perspective that’s not a win

[00:16:44,239]: And we spent tens of billions of dollars in Syria

[00:16:49,559]: We lost lives

[00:16:52,039]: You know we know Joe Kent you know his story his wife absolute heroic woman

[00:16:58,659]: You know other soldiers Marines were wounded

[00:17:02,460]: We came close at several points to getting a combat with the actual Russian military

[00:17:08,619]: We had a major battle with Russian mercenaries a Wagner group

[00:17:14,040]: You know a lot of people focus on the risk of escalation in Ukraine

[00:17:17,880]: And an incident where American and Russian forces that are operating area could come into conflict and where that could go

[00:17:26,900]: That that almost happened in Syria on a weekly basis for several years because you had Russian and Syrian or you had Russian and American aircraft operating the same place

[00:17:35,339]: You had American troops and Russian troops operating the same area

[00:17:39,839]: One misunderstanding could have kicked off a cycle where weren’t a major conflict with And you know the focus has been on Ukraine but the place for the longest time where Russian and American forces were brushing up against each other was in Syria

[00:17:56,699]: So especially after the destruction of ISIS caliphate that mission should have ended

[00:18:01,800]: And it is again an absolute crime that it was undermined not once but twice in President Trump’s first term

[00:18:09,270]: You described our troop presence in Iraq as quote a tripwire

[00:18:15,239]: Can you flesh out what you mean by that and how it happened

[00:18:19,219]: I would say both Iraq and Syria and probably more Syria is that kind of gets to

[00:18:26,760]: Ultimately why I think some people wanted to keep our troops there is that if there was a mass casualty incident where an Iranian aligned militia or some other actor attacked American troops and you know God forbid killed or wounded a significant number of troops that would have been justification to escalate either against Iran or to get more involved fighting other groups like you know al Qaeda ISIS

[00:18:57,160]: And so just their mere presence was again they weren’t effectively deterring Iran or other actors because they’re just too small but their presence in itself was a risk that we could be sucked into a major war

[00:19:11,599]: So are you saying that you sincerely believe there are U S policymakers who intentionally put American troops at risk

[00:19:19,420]: I don’t think consciously there are U S at least I don’t want to believe

[00:19:26,959]: No there are U S policymakers that believe that

[00:19:30,280]: But you know I think subconsciously some folks did

[00:19:35,020]: Lyndon Johnson allowed the USS Liberty to be attacked

[00:19:37,099]: He knew those guys were going to die

[00:19:38,119]: He thought they’re all going to die

[00:19:38,979]: I mean I think that’s true

[00:19:40,420]: So I mean that’s happened before

[00:19:42,040]: He’s the president of the United States allowing hoping for the death of U S troops for some other agenda

[00:19:48,640]: Like there are people that evil

[00:19:50,219]: Lyndon Johnson was that evil

[00:19:51,380]: Yeah

[00:19:51,660]: I mean you know what we know now about Gulf of Tonkin and all that other I think so

[00:19:56,619]: Oh exactly

[00:19:57,079]: Exactly

[00:19:57,520]: And I you know my belief is is that honestly a lot of it more had to do and we talked about this last interview this kind of policy inertia

[00:20:07,619]: Like it’s easier just to say let’s keep doing the status quo as opposed to actually changing something because there’s less risk in a lot of people’s minds

[00:20:19,479]: Now again I just laid out the risk of keeping troops there

[00:20:22,300]: But in some people’s minds there’s less risk to their career by preserving the status quo as opposed to changing something that’s not working

[00:20:31,000]: So Roe v

[00:20:32,420]: Wade was overturned three years ago and people celebrated

[00:20:34,739]: But the battle over abortion is not over

[00:20:38,619]: In fact did you know that abortions are at a 10 year high

[00:20:42,680]: In a lot of ways it’s the saddest thing that happens in this country

[00:20:45,880]: The birth rate falls and the killing of children accelerates

[00:20:50,699]: It’s awful

[00:20:52,199]: Preborn is fighting this trend

[00:20:54,280]: They’re expanding their life affirming care in the darkest corners of the country to help women and save babies

[00:20:59,020]: Now the abortion mafia don’t want women to think about what they are carrying

[00:21:03,760]: They want them to think that ending the pregnancy will solve all of their problems

[00:21:06,660]: But that is not true

[00:21:08,160]: 11 of women who take the abortion pill for example go on to suffer serious health consequences

[00:21:13,540]: And that does not include the emotional and moral consequences

[00:21:17,959]: It’s bad

[00:21:19,420]: It’s ending a life

[00:21:20,479]: So when you give to Preborn you are not just saving a baby you’re saving a mother too

[00:21:25,420]: Preborn has already rescued over 350 000 babies

[00:21:28,180]: There are still many many more who need help

[00:21:31,000]: Dial pound 250 and say the keyword baby to support their cause

[00:21:34,079]: That’s pound 250 baby

[00:21:36,380]: Go to preborn com

[00:21:37,760]: slash Tucker preborn com

[00:21:39,199]: slash Tucker because children are the greatest gift period

[00:21:44,180]: And regardless of motive I think your point is demonstrably true

[00:21:49,800]: Whether or not the people who set it up intended it to be a tripwire it is a tripwire

[00:21:53,500]: Yes

[00:21:54,099]: That’s fair right

[00:21:55,180]: Yes absolutely

[00:21:56,640]: So that’s the first thing that could happen if we strike if the U S military strikes offensively against Iran in any way right

[00:22:06,660]: So okay so then what else

[00:22:09,119]: What would happen then

[00:22:09,900]: Well that’s where there’s really it all depends on the impact of the counter strike on U S troops and on American facilities and how the United States responds

[00:22:25,459]: If we continue at that point you’re on the escalation ladder

[00:22:28,920]: So if our troops are attacked and we counter attack with a larger strike and a larger force and if we use certain bases in the region like say in places like Qatar Kuwait Bahrain the Emirates Saudi Arabia if these countries allow us and there’s a good chance this is something I think needs to be constantly reinforced is that these Gulf Arab states are not where they were in 2019

[00:22:58,359]: So it’s not a guarantee that they would allow us to use these bases in their country to attack Iran

[00:23:04,819]: But if the Iranians perceive whether it’s true or not that we are using those bases and they’re looking to punish us they will attack bases that are larger maybe more hardened but host a lot more troops

[00:23:21,540]: And that could quickly lead to more casualties

[00:23:24,979]: They can also attack ships in the Arabian Sea or Persian Gulf

[00:23:31,439]: And they could also if we continue to get pushed up the escalation ladder attack U S diplomatic facilities

[00:23:37,660]: Now those are all worst case scenarios but they’re risks that should be considered and can’t be ignored

[00:23:44,420]: So it gets back to this whole idea that I just

[00:23:47,719]: And again I hope I’m wrong

[00:23:49,400]: I fundamentally don’t buy that you can just do one or two strikes and that’s it and the Iranians you know aren’t going to respond it’s going to have to be you’re going to have to prepare and expect a much longer and much more bloody military campaign

[00:24:06,599]: Obviously without divulging the details of any kind of classified planning document we know that the Pentagon has been thinking about how Iran would respond to a strike against its enrichment facilities for like a long time a long long time

[00:24:20,139]: This has been I mean people have and I know that you’re one of them

[00:24:24,019]: Does anybody think that they just wouldn’t respond

[00:24:30,819]: I’m sure there are people right now who are trying to say is they won’t respond it’s like they’re weak they’re on their back foot they want to just save the regime so therefore they’re just going to back off that they’re not actually going to respond

[00:24:48,619]: And if you look at the hours immediately after the Israeli initial Israeli set of airstrikes there’s some people saying watch like Iran’s not going to really respond or it’s going to be weak

[00:25:04,659]: And you know over the next few days they launched between 400 and 500 ballistic missiles

[00:25:10,439]: Again thankfully they weren’t as effective as originally advertised but still they’ve as we sit here today I believe killed around 25 Israelis wounded nearly 600

[00:25:21,719]: They’ve been able to hit you know

[00:25:25,379]: They’ve wounded 600 Israelis so far

[00:25:28,059]: Yeah

[00:25:28,979]: Are we there’s total military censorship in Israel

[00:25:32,919]: Israeli citizens are not allowed to leave

[00:25:34,599]: Most of them are not allowed to leave the country

[00:25:36,119]: They shut it down

[00:25:37,059]: So like they’re stuck there for people

[00:25:40,699]: And so and there’s you know total control of the press in Israel

[00:25:44,379]: So do we know like are we confident we know the casualty numbers in Israel

[00:25:50,379]: No both sides the numbers that have been released by both sides are in some cases maybe overstating things

[00:25:58,119]: I think it’s likely the Iranians are maybe overstating civilian casualties understating military casualties

[00:26:05,419]: You would guess

[00:26:05,919]: And I think it’s a lagging indicator

[00:26:08,299]: My understanding and again I’m not an expert on this is that the way the Israelis work is that they allow the information to come out at just a later point

[00:26:16,999]: But look I mean in some ways I don’t blame them because somebody filming something from a balcony and how a missile hits that is intelligence for the Iranians

[00:26:28,339]: Oh I’m not complaining about it

[00:26:29,439]: I’m just saying I always And you saw something you see that very in Ukraine as well

[00:26:36,019]: Yeah

[00:26:36,239]: I mean that’s a whole different I mean the casualty numbers in Ukraine you know extended this war for years at the expense of the Ukrainians I think have a moral obligation to know how many Ukrainians have died

[00:26:49,239]: They did this

[00:26:50,739]: But they don’t care

[00:26:52,139]: I actually think there was an amendment and I could be wrong about this put in one of the National Defense Authorization Acts or an attempt to force the disclosure of the two true casualty numbers and I think it was defeated or it was added in and just it’s being ignored by DOD

[00:27:07,639]: Yeah I really think that’s contemptible

[00:27:09,939]: I’ve asked a bunch of lawmakers who have are really responsible for the war or the continuation of the war you know like how many Ukrainians have died

[00:27:19,939]: They have no interest in knowing you know but anyway

[00:27:22,719]: The point of walking all that through that is there and Iran is really adjusting and changing their tactics as the war grinds on and that’s in part because Israelis have been successful in destroying some of their mobile missile launchers and their missile stocks so the barrages aren’t as intense but you’re seeing them introduce new systems and here’s the most important thing that you know absent an American intervention which as we’ve discussed could be imminent right now the war is essentially a race between Iran and Israel

[00:28:03,459]: For the Israelis they are trying to destroy as many Iranian ballistic missile launchers and ballistic missiles before they run out of anti missile ballistic missile interceptors for their Arrow and David Sling systems and then our THAAD systems and our SM 3 SM 6s that we’re launching off of ships

[00:28:25,159]: Likewise the Iranians are trying to preserve as many of their missile systems and survive as many Israeli airstrikes as possible while the Israelis wear down their store of precision munitions and missile interceptors so each side is trying to get to a point where they’re either not threatened by certain offensive weapon systems or their offensive weapon systems can breach defensive systems more effectively and inflict more casualties and they’re smart people that say right now in that race Israel has a slight advantage other smart people say Iran has a slight advantage because of the number of missiles they’ve stockpiled and that really right now is the game so there’s a time pressure here on both sides and absent you know American military intervention which will change the whole dynamic is that’s really what it’s going to come down to which side can outlast the other with certain types of weapons and weapon systems

[00:29:30,379]: Again with the caveat I have no freaking idea what’s going to happen nobody does other than well I don’t know that anybody does right now I mean it has been reported repeatedly that there’s going to be American military intervention like that’s just like reported as fact whether it is or not so I just want to focus a little more intently on how does that change the dynamic and how much offensive intervention would qualify as like dragging America into the war officially Annie

[00:30:03,259]: Well again a lot of it goes that goes back to the conversation we’re just having if Iran doesn’t respond to just one or two strikes they decide to take that blow and there’s evidence that they most of the evidence shows they probably wouldn’t then that would probably contain the size of the American offensive operation

[00:30:26,119]: But if we were to go in I think it is likely that we wouldn’t just hit a nuclear site for the sake of our own troops so it would not just be a one off strike or we’d coordinate with Israelis

[00:30:40,999]: And again if there is an attack on American bases in response to this that would pull the United States more into the war and push us into a spiral where we’re constantly escalating against the other side

[00:30:55,339]: And then that brings us to a point where even though it’s pretty clear the Trump administration even if they do decide to do the strike doesn’t want a regime change war is ultimately get pulled into a regime change war whether or not we want it

[00:31:09,599]: So none of this was even on the table you know 10 days ago until the Prime Minister of Israel called the President of the United States and said I’m going and I’m doing it I don’t care what you say

[00:31:19,499]: It’s all been reported in the New York Times given three days notice

[00:31:23,099]: It’s just a little bit crazy that all of a sudden we’re talking about like how are we going to deal with this war against Iran which wasn’t even a thing two weeks ago

[00:31:30,819]: So I just want to say that

[00:31:33,439]: If this were a war that the United States chose this wasn’t this war that was chosen for us we’re going along with it

[00:31:40,439]: But if we had chosen this if we decided like depending on HQ we’re going to take out those enrichment facilities how like you wouldn’t do it three days later right

[00:31:51,419]: There’s a lot of planning for these things

[00:31:53,979]: Yes

[00:31:54,359]: And this is I mean again stuff that’s been publicly reported

[00:31:57,399]: These types of operations have been planned for years

[00:32:00,879]: And they’ve had different plans they’ve adjusted but have essentially been on the shelf for years now

[00:32:08,459]: Yeah

[00:32:09,659]: But does it make it harder to get just three days notice before the shooting starts

[00:32:16,679]: This is where I’m a little unsure because I don’t know what 100 for sure there’s a lot of public reporting but that’s not always so

[00:32:24,599]: That’s right

[00:32:25,239]: You’re absolutely right

[00:32:26,219]: And I shouldn’t pretend like I know

[00:32:27,559]: And so I don’t know what was in the region or not but to successfully accomplish something like this you do need a there needs to be a lot of things that happen leading up into that

[00:32:41,079]: I think that is fair to say

[00:32:42,739]: And the United States military can move quickly when it needs to I’ll say it can move quickly when you don’t have large number of ground troops when you’re primarily relying on air and naval assets

[00:32:55,039]: So you can move stuff in quickly

[00:32:57,719]: But leading up into that there would have there normally would be a lot of planning

[00:33:02,119]: But again I’m sorry if I’m going back and forth here

[00:33:04,839]: This has been a scenario that has been planned for for a long time

[00:33:08,019]: If there’s one thing we’ve learned over the past couple of years it’s that when things go south unexpectedly and they do you are in charge of your family’s health and safety not the authorities you

[00:33:19,959]: And so prepare think it through ahead of time

[00:33:22,519]: You remember that during the dark days of COVID for example you kept hearing about a medication a medicine called ivermectin

[00:33:28,999]: Doctors have used ivermectin for decades treating parasites viruses even studying it as a potential cancer treatment

[00:33:34,699]: But you are not allowed to use it

[00:33:36,179]: In fact you’re a bad person if you even use the word

[00:33:39,599]: But at JACE they’ve thought this through and they’ve looked at the evidence that doctors at JACE have created a powerful anti parasite formula made with a blend that includes ivermectin

[00:33:50,799]: It’s the fastest most affordable option on the market and getting it actually is simple

[00:33:55,759]: Getting that and other life saving medications is just a matter of going to JACE com

[00:34:00,739]: JACE is J A C E

[00:34:02,399]: You fill out a brief online consultation and a JACE doctor quickly reviews your information

[00:34:07,119]: Within minutes your medication could be on its way to you delivered right to your door

[00:34:11,379]: That and a lot of other life saving medications

[00:34:14,439]: So don’t wait till there’s a disaster

[00:34:16,599]: Take back control of your family’s health and safety

[00:34:18,759]: You can get emergency antibiotics as well

[00:34:21,379]: Go to JACE com

[00:34:22,779]: Use the discount code TUCKER

[00:34:25,119]: JACE com discount code TUCKER

[00:34:27,739]: In thinking about this non classified of course but given that Iran is part of BRICS and has all kinds of military and economic ties with Russia and China how high is the concern that they might get involved

[00:34:42,519]: So this is where it gets interesting is I think Russia in particular has a lot of reasons for them not to get involved

[00:34:55,999]: That’s my sense

[00:34:57,259]: And the reason there’s a few reasons is one a lot of the things that Iran would need from Russia are actually things that Russians really need in Ukraine

[00:35:05,979]: So air defense assets fighter jets and things like that is Russia’s military and industrial base is much more developed than the United States and NATO

[00:35:17,159]: Interesting fact

[00:35:19,739]: And you know the NATO Secretary General says all the time is Russia produces more weapons and munitions in three months than all of NATO combined produces in a year

[00:35:30,899]: But the Russian way of war in Ukraine relies on overwhelming firepower

[00:35:36,399]: So it’s very difficult for them to divert weapons to other partners

[00:35:41,359]: I’m not saying that that couldn’t happen

[00:35:44,219]: Maybe there’s some intelligence sharing

[00:35:45,679]: But I don’t think that my gut would be is they would not support Iran in a very big way

[00:35:51,619]: I think China is different

[00:35:54,319]: I don’t think that they would overtly support the Iranians

[00:35:57,959]: But I think if there’s one party that over the medium term at least and they may face some short term challenges because of disruption and energy surprise but over the medium term that would benefit from another major war in the Middle East where the United States is heavily involved in it is China

[00:36:16,859]: Because the weapons that we would be using to fight Iran are what we would need in a Pacific contingency

[00:36:25,999]: And God forbid we fight a war with China

[00:36:28,839]: It’s not even fighting war either

[00:36:30,119]: It’s weapons that we want to supply to some of our partners whether it’s Japan or the Philippines or South Korea or Taiwan

[00:36:38,039]: Those are all systems that would be heavily used whether it’s air defense standoff munitions other types of air to surface munitions surface to surface munitions

[00:36:53,379]: Those are the things that are going to lead the Iran fight because of just the size of Iran is a huge country both in terms of population but geography it’s not as small in terms of geography as Iraq

[00:37:06,259]: And it’s much longer distances to say get from the Persian Gulf up to Tehran

[00:37:11,519]: So you have to rely on certain types of weapons and certain types of aircraft again all of which would be at the tip of a spear in a fight against China

[00:37:20,239]: So it is in their interest to see us expend more and more munitions and wear down more and more weapon systems in the Persian Gulf

[00:37:28,939]: So again China’s played it very smart in how they engage the Middle East

[00:37:33,059]: I think that they would be more willing to do things economically to help Iran and maybe provide some non lethal systems like they have for Russia that could be beneficial for Iran in this fight

[00:37:47,419]: But again you can’t

[00:37:48,819]: What do you mean by non lethal systems

[00:37:50,859]: So for example China there’s debate over this but there’s not really clear evidence that China has provided lethal weapons systems like Iran and North Korea had to Russia

[00:38:04,719]: However they have provided non lethal weapons systems like counter drone technology to Russia

[00:38:11,179]: They have provided they’ve helped them get around some of the Western sanctions

[00:38:15,779]: They’ve helped provide them certain types of electronics that are maybe harder to get from the West

[00:38:20,279]: I think we can say that with confidence

[00:38:22,119]: They could do that with Iran

[00:38:24,259]: And massive investment in Russia which by the way keeps the Russian population prosperous and happy and not complaining about the war

[00:38:32,939]: But again as we’ve talked about before that’s not a natural alliance

[00:38:39,359]: And the Russian security services are still very suspicious of the Chinese just like the Iranian security services aren’t

[00:38:47,319]: They’re still suspicious of the Russians because there’s a long history of Russia invading and trying to border each other

[00:38:57,219]: Occupying Iran I believe twice in the 20th century

[00:39:01,739]: So getting back to the theme that we’ve talked about before is like we’ve helped push these countries together because of our dumb foreign policy

[00:39:08,519]: We should be able to pull them apart

[00:39:10,319]: They should have natural tension

[00:39:11,659]: But because of our foreign policy over the last 30 years we’re creating these opportunities for cooperation

[00:39:17,199]: And that makes the situation in the Middle East worse the situation in Ukraine worse and the situation in the Pacific worse for us

[00:39:25,279]: Do you think there’s any chance that China become you know if this does become a direct conflict between the United States and Iran that China enters it in a way that’s like that we can’t ignore that’s just so provocative that we’re at war with them too

[00:39:40,099]: I think it’s more likely that they would make a decision to do something in the Pacific because that is more important to them

[00:39:47,599]: I don’t buy this argument that if we were to pull out of the Middle East that China would want to become a hegemon in the Middle East

[00:39:59,339]: They have been able to use smart power and minimal military power to maintain influence and reap economic benefits from the Middle East

[00:40:07,999]: And they don’t have the force projection capabilities that the United States has

[00:40:14,019]: Some smart people that I’ve worked with have made pretty compelling arguments that they are not likely to try and dominate the Middle East

[00:40:23,679]: So I don’t think China would get directly involved in the Middle East

[00:40:28,499]: But if they see the United States worn down even more in the Middle East that may change some of their calculus vis a vis Taiwan

[00:40:36,719]: And I wonder not just Taiwan

[00:40:38,579]: So we’ve been in Japan for 80 years

[00:40:41,379]: We’ve been in Korea since 1950 75 years

[00:40:46,019]: Those are like in their neighborhood

[00:40:49,279]: Yeah

[00:40:49,679]: And I’m certainly not justifying anything China does

[00:40:52,579]: I’m not

[00:40:52,919]: But I’m just trying to understand their perspective because I think it’s meaningful

[00:40:57,179]: If there was an 80 year old Chinese military base in Belize you’d be like a little close

[00:41:03,479]: We wouldn’t want that

[00:41:04,699]: Nobody wants that

[00:41:05,859]: And so maybe their expectation is that they can drive us out of the East out of their direct sphere

[00:41:12,299]: Is that a concern

[00:41:13,859]: I mean is that something that people think this stuff through think about

[00:41:19,739]: Yeah I think there have been people that have thought about that

[00:41:22,879]: And I think there’s a lot of people

[00:41:24,619]: Honestly I think one of the biggest issues the Pentagon is dealing with right now is since that has been identified as the main theater the main threat the pacing to use military terms the pacing threat or pacing challenge whatever term you want to use that everything we’re doing in the Middle East trades off against the Pacific which from an economic standpoint is much more important to us than the Middle East

[00:41:53,719]: What happens in the South China Sea is fundamentally more important than what happens in the Middle East

[00:42:00,719]: Middle East I think is 5 of the world’s population 5 of the GDP

[00:42:07,879]: East Asia is something like 60 40 or 60 of the world’s GDP

[00:42:13,739]: So just from a trade and the conditions of our economic prosperity standpoint it is much more important to us

[00:42:21,119]: And China is an actual real existential threat to the United States where Iran is a threat in so much that we have 40 000 troops spread across the Middle East many of them who are in exposed positions as we’ve talked about that are vulnerable to Iranian attacks

[00:42:40,839]: That’s the biggest reason why they’re a threat

[00:42:43,039]: I don’t know

[00:42:43,359]: I don’t think you watch Fox News

[00:42:44,979]: I heard Ted Cruz say that the Iranians are going to nuke L A

[00:42:49,919]: Well as of right now they don’t have a nuclear bomb

[00:42:53,939]: One interesting thing is is Iran has not developed missiles that go beyond a certain range

[00:43:01,439]: Doesn’t mean they can’t but they have been hesitant to up until this point because they don’t want to be seen as threatening countries outside their region

[00:43:10,959]: So why is Ted Cruz saying they’re going to nuke L A

[00:43:13,239]: I think and again I’ve been a big Ted Cruz fan over the years

[00:43:18,059]: I’ve come to you know respect him on many levels

[00:43:21,499]: I think he is repeating a talking point to help raise the level in people’s minds a level of threat that Iran actually imposed

[00:43:32,779]: In order to justify American involvement in regime change

[00:43:37,059]: Correct

[00:43:37,479]: Let’s be honest

[00:43:38,659]: Iran has been a bad actor in the Middle East

[00:43:41,759]: They’ve been a they have been a major sponsor of terrorism indisputably

[00:43:46,479]: But I believe their economy is the size of Pennsylvania

[00:43:50,459]: Saudi Arabia alone spends four times what they do on defense

[00:43:54,259]: They’re bordered by Pakistan that has a nuclear weapon and they have pretty decent relationship right now

[00:44:01,139]: But over the years there’s been tension because Pakistan Sunni Iran Shia you have Israel with a very capable nuclear triad and very capable army

[00:44:11,159]: So they’re surrounded by countries in the region that have historical antagonisms with them

[00:44:18,459]: And they simply right now do not possess the capability to hit the United States with conventional weapons

[00:44:25,119]: What they do and this is something we’ve talked about need to be concerned about is they do have the ability to infiltrate terrorists in other countries

[00:44:35,459]: That is a risk

[00:44:36,739]: That is something we need to take into account but is not existential like the threat posed by China with what is quickly emerging as the biggest navy in the world with hundreds of nuclear weapons including intercontinental ballistic missiles against the United States

[00:44:50,999]: China that could shut off a significant amount of trade and economic activity to the United States and harm us in significant ways

[00:45:02,859]: Iran is simply not an existential threat in the same way that China is and even Russia is with 6 000 nuclear weapons

[00:45:09,299]: So why are we so focused on Iran

[00:45:11,839]: There are a lot of reasons

[00:45:14,479]: They can’t be strictly limited to our national interest given what you just said

[00:45:18,599]: Again it goes back to first and foremost and I know people want to talk about a whole host of other things but really the thing that is driving this the most and our focus on Iran and the Middle East as a whole is that too many of our policymakers still believe in the idea that America needs to be not simply the most powerful country in the world but the most dominant power in the world that we need to have dominance in a way that we are able to impose our values on other parts of the world that have rejected mainly liberalism that we need to use our dominance to achieve liberal hegemony

[00:46:01,919]: And that leads us into conflict with countries in regions that really shouldn’t matter as much to us as they should

[00:46:10,619]: And we do have some interests in the Middle East to be clear and I can walk through those

[00:46:14,639]: But the countries that just don’t pose the type of threat that a lot of people in Washington hype them up

[00:46:19,899]: Wouldn’t it be easier if you’re the Iranian government just to observe Pride Month in Tehran and just get this over with

[00:46:28,219]: And then there’s no threat of an attack right

[00:46:31,499]: Well as Bret Stephens told my friend Sourabh Amari he wants to ultimately see the 82nd born in the streets of Tehran you know escorting a gay pride parade

[00:46:42,619]: And that kind of that kind of sums that up

[00:46:44,719]: Bret Stephens said that

[00:46:45,619]: Yeah

[00:46:46,905]: Man I’ve known a lot of people in 56 years I don’t know I’ve ever met anybody weirder and dumber than Bret Stephens but that’s just me

[00:46:53,865]: I actually this is going to sound weird

[00:46:56,785]: I respect him because he just says it out loud

[00:47:00,345]: He says yeah I want the United States to be the most dominant power in the world to spread liberal values

[00:47:08,105]: I want the United States to pursue progress

[00:47:10,485]: Bret Stephens is not even from this country

[00:47:11,665]: I mean it’s like getting a lecture about America from Bret Stephens is like

[00:47:15,245]: Again I just have

[00:47:17,665]: I’m pretty sure he’s from Mexico but whatever

[00:47:20,025]: He is

[00:47:21,225]: Yeah

[00:47:21,545]: He’s from Mexico

[00:47:22,185]: I didn’t know that

[00:47:22,865]: But again in a weird way I obviously find his views abhorrent

[00:47:26,585]: I mean he’s said absolutely fundamentally racist things about Arabs and other people

[00:47:34,185]: He’s got a weird obsession with genetics but he’s honest

[00:47:37,885]: He doesn’t try to like wrap it in this cloak of American interests and American values

[00:47:45,925]: He just comes out and says it and again in a weird way I kind of appreciate that

[00:47:51,325]: Yeah

[00:47:51,365]: No I mean I guess that’s where the being an idiot kind of plays into it

[00:47:58,045]: He just kind of says it out loud

[00:47:58,905]: Isn’t it funny essentially that I think you have what three or four New York Times op ed writers that believe exactly what he believes

[00:48:09,845]: I mean David Brooks David French him Tom Friedman’s kind of evolving

[00:48:17,325]: I don’t even know where Tom Friedman is these days but essentially they Bethesda

[00:48:20,865]: Yeah

[00:48:22,525]: They hold the same views

[00:48:25,365]: The supposed left wing paper and there’s some look they’ve you know credit New York Times

[00:48:30,905]: Sometimes they do have some good stuff on their op ed pages but you know you essentially have four op ed columnists that believe essentially the same thing

[00:48:40,185]: They just express it differently

[00:48:41,665]: Like David French would never be that

[00:48:43,445]: David French would be the guy that masks it and like this is what’s good for America and America But they’re all violence worshipers David French especially and there is a kind of like weak man compensates through promoting killing in other parts of the world

[00:48:59,685]: You know it’s like oh this sort of same weird cuck syndrome they all have

[00:49:04,885]: No it is though

[00:49:06,065]: It is

[00:49:06,545]: I mean you don’t have to be Sigmund Freud to see like David French is like a psychosexual thing that’s going on here

[00:49:11,205]: Yeah

[00:49:11,905]: Yeah

[00:49:12,265]: Oh they’re so handsome

[00:49:13,105]: I mean I will say this David is you know I’m a much bigger dick than you are and I’m sorry

[00:49:19,265]: You’re such a nice person

[00:49:20,065]: No well you bring up certain people I will be a dick

[00:49:22,705]: I think David he’s so interesting because he brought away such a much different and I know there’s people that you know mocked his military service

[00:49:34,965]: I’m not going to do that but he brought away like a much different understanding of his service in Iraq than a lot of other people and I’ve just kind of found that fascinating

[00:49:44,445]: And I think in a lot of ways his views are really increasingly the way he talks about foreign policy I think he’s more of a barometer of where the center of the Democrat Party is than the dying neoconservative fringe of the Republican Party is

[00:50:05,665]: He is representing increasingly where the Democrat Party is not the Republican Party on foreign policy

[00:50:11,325]: And we brought this up last time remember the Democrat Party platform in 2020 was more hawkish on Iran

[00:50:23,385]: They did a 180 from excuse me in 2024 they did a 180 from where they were in 2020 on Iran in 2024 and it was more hawkish and there’s a world where you could add Liz Cheney as a national security advisor or as a secretary of defense

[00:50:37,765]: That’s just the darkest thing I can imagine

[00:50:39,385]: So I just want to go back to something you said a second ago you said the dying Republican neocon fringe

[00:50:46,565]: Of course I love the sound of that but it’s hard to see you’re looking obviously more broadly than I am because right now I see Fox News as just this pure crazed neocon war propaganda operation Mark Levin the least credible person in broadcasting is like in charge of the government

[00:51:05,305]: I mean I’m overstating of course but it’s like they seem very powerful right now

[00:51:08,725]: That part of the Republican Party Mitch McConnell Tom Cotton Ted Cruz Mark Levin but you’re saying they’re a dying fringe

[00:51:19,845]: Again it’s looking at it right now it’s very easy to think that the neocons have once again taken over the foreign policy apparatus of the Republican Party but I think we need to look at a couple of things

[00:51:34,585]: There is no popular support for going to war directly with Iran

[00:51:42,125]: We have to acknowledge there is concern about Iran getting a nuclear weapon but there’s not a constituency for going to war with Iran and there hasn’t really ever been one but most of your Republican voters don’t want this

[00:51:56,345]: I looked up the numbers the polling numbers and I think the AIDS virus is more popular than the idea of going to war with Iran

[00:52:02,445]: I think it’s actually 16 national support

[00:52:05,365]: Yeah and that was from YouGov Brookings has done polls the University of Maryland

[00:52:10,445]: There was one joke of a poll that was clearly manipulated as being circulated by neocons but there’s poll after poll from both liberal nonpartisan conservative institutions show there’s not broad support for this

[00:52:22,785]: In addition you now have within the administration a lot of people that don’t look like the types of people that used to staff Republican administrations mainly George W Bush administration but also you could argue the first Trump term in terms of foreign policy

[00:52:41,225]: These are people like Bridge Colby people like Joe Kent people like Michael Anton who have different ideas about American foreign policy and are much different than say the people that a Paul Wolfowitz or a John Bolton would hire into administration

[00:52:57,745]: So they don’t have a lot of people within the power structure right now at least on the political side within the career side and the military absolutely

[00:53:10,125]: And then in addition you have to acknowledge is that there’s now an institutional structure that didn’t exist in 2016 of organizations that are able to get a message out around foreign policy that challenges what Ben Rhodes called the blob even though he’s a card carrying member of the blob these traditional organizations that push for American primacy and intervention

[00:53:33,785]: So you have a lot of pieces coming together that show that neoconservatism on the right is in retreat

[00:53:43,325]: But that’s in a lot of cases when movements can be most dangerous is that I really sense in a lot of ways why they have gone all out is because they’re desperate is they see particularly on the right the younger cohort coming up

[00:53:58,225]: And we talked about this

[00:53:59,385]: A lot of these people make you and me look like Paul Wolfowitz in terms of our foreign policy beliefs

[00:54:04,685]: I feel very much

[00:54:05,605]: I mean I always say this but I feel very moderate

[00:54:07,425]: I am very moderate just by temperament

[00:54:09,905]: And I don’t meet really any moderate young people in these questions at all

[00:54:15,265]: And they see that

[00:54:16,305]: So that’s why there is such an all out effort right now to push this because they think it’s their last chance

[00:54:23,325]: I think they’re right

[00:54:25,505]: I think they’re right

[00:54:27,925]: So I think even now we’re sort of officially clinging to the idea that Israel’s goal here is a non nuclear Iran

[00:54:39,145]: That’s not true

[00:54:40,145]: Their goal is regime change

[00:54:41,225]: I think it’s fair to say

[00:54:43,185]: But I do think Donald Trump’s goal is not regime change

[00:54:45,765]: I don’t think he wants to be

[00:54:47,085]: I know he doesn’t want to be in a regime change where he doesn’t want Iran to have a bomb

[00:54:50,425]: He said that a million times

[00:54:52,325]: My question is a practical one

[00:54:54,565]: Is it possible to shut down a nuclear program with an air campaign

[00:55:01,025]: I think you can roll it back

[00:55:02,545]: I think you can severely damage it

[00:55:05,105]: But look I’ll use an argument that the advocates of the Iraq war made is that you can’t truly shut down a weapons of mass destruction campaign with certain people in charge of the country

[00:55:19,325]: You can’t truly shut it down because you can’t trust inspectors

[00:55:23,645]: You can’t truly trust intelligence

[00:55:26,825]: They were doing that in a very manipulative way

[00:55:28,845]: But there’s a sliver of truth in that

[00:55:30,385]: So if you truly want to get rid of an Iranian nuclear weapon program and make sure it’s totally dismantled it’s likely going to require a regime change or some type of occupation or invasion

[00:55:48,265]: That may sound extreme but if you stop and think about it that’s the truth

[00:55:53,985]: Now you can roll it again

[00:55:55,945]: So I have thought about it but not as deeply as you have I would bet

[00:55:59,505]: Can you flesh that out a little bit

[00:56:01,665]: Why would an air campaign not solve the nuclear problem

[00:56:06,605]: Because you would need to verify that all the centrifuges are destroyed

[00:56:11,085]: You need to verify that all the knowledge both scientists other engineers that they are accounted for in some cases killed that there’s no files remaining and that all the centrifuges all the different pieces all the nuclear material the triggers anything that could be part of this are destroyed

[00:56:34,445]: And then any development of the delivery systems it is incredibly difficult to do that

[00:56:41,565]: It’s impossible to do that purely through air

[00:56:43,945]: You’re going to need inspections

[00:56:46,345]: You’re going to need people on the ground verifying this

[00:56:49,225]: And again what we’ve seen before is the argument that the inspectors aren’t going to find everything

[00:56:54,425]: So I think you can kind of see where this is going

[00:56:58,145]: And so the argument likely that you’re going to see and it’s not totally incorrect is that to truly get rid of the threat of a nuclear Iran an Islamic Republic with a nuclear bomb is you’re going to need regime change

[00:57:10,545]: And so as I said previously that’s why in my mind this really isn’t about a nuclear bomb

[00:57:17,465]: And I want to be clear for President Trump it is

[00:57:19,445]: And for a lot of good people who rightly are concerned about nuclear Iran it is about that

[00:57:26,565]: But for a lot of others it’s about regime change

[00:57:28,725]: And I think that the consequences of that for the United States for the Middle East even for Israel have not been thought through

[00:57:36,545]: Because a lot of people just like in Iraq they aren’t thinking about what comes next if we get rid of Iran as an Islamic Republic

[00:57:44,445]: We just had the Iraq War

[00:57:45,965]: I mean that was it only started 22 years ago

[00:57:51,025]: And we still have troops there

[00:57:52,905]: We just got out of Afghanistan a few years ago after 20 years

[00:57:57,065]: Like the memory is not just fresh

[00:57:59,285]: It’s not even a memory

[00:58:00,105]: It’s still a present reality

[00:58:01,205]: We still have troops there

[00:58:02,565]: What are you talking about

[00:58:03,365]: I mean Iraq is a thriving liberal democracy

[00:58:09,445]: Afghanistan just achieved 100 female literacy

[00:58:13,765]: Which was always the goal

[00:58:16,265]: You know I don’t know what you’re talking about

[00:58:18,325]: But you know joking aside is there’s still a lot of people who think we can do this

[00:58:28,105]: That we can actually change a regime and instill liberalism through the barrel of a gun

[00:58:37,765]: There is still that thinking in Washington D C They have learned nothing from Iraq from Syria from Libya from Afghanistan from Yemen from other places

[00:58:48,305]: It just it does not work

[00:58:50,885]: My problem is bigger which is what happens to the American empire which is obviously contracting

[00:58:57,465]: We don’t have the will or the money to sustain it at current levels obviously

[00:59:01,725]: You know we are challenged by China and maybe other countries for you know supremacy over shipping lanes and over the air and all this you know things are changing really really fast

[00:59:14,965]: So the empire is getting smaller but there’s got to be a way to unwind it slowly thoughtfully with minimal damage

[00:59:25,625]: I think our adversaries not even enemies but just challengers to our position would like to crumble in one day

[00:59:32,585]: So there’s this incentive to really kick the legs out from under America right now

[00:59:37,445]: Do you feel that

[00:59:39,665]: I believe so

[00:59:40,725]: Yeah

[00:59:40,965]: I think so and there again there’s a lot of people I think in China that would love us to see bogged down in the Middle East

[00:59:53,485]: You and I you know we don’t believe that we should be involved in the Ukraine war but if you’re somebody that thinks that you know Ukraine is the most important thing for a liberal democracy this war is going to make it harder if not impossible to support Ukraine

[01:00:12,425]: You know it’s going to make it harder

[01:00:14,385]: Why is that

[01:00:15,805]: Why would a war with Iran make it impossible to continue supporting Ukraine

[01:00:19,325]: Good question

[01:00:19,865]: So after the October 7th attacks you had Joe Biden go on 60 Minutes and say after he was asked by the host I forget what host it was but he was asked are we going to be able to support both Israel and Ukraine

[01:00:36,545]: And you know his dying brain said oh come on man

[01:00:39,225]: Of course we can

[01:00:39,945]: We’re the most powerful country ever

[01:00:41,565]: We won World War II

[01:00:42,825]: Of course we can do both

[01:00:44,525]: And a week later the United States was forced to redirect a shipment of artillery shells from Ukraine to Israel to support them in their fight against Hamas

[01:00:55,145]: And that right there just shattered the illusion that we can do both

[01:00:59,245]: Of artillery shells

[01:01:00,265]: So pretty low tech stuff

[01:01:02,025]: Right

[01:01:02,385]: And we had about I believe six seven months prior to October 7th when Netanyahu was out of power for a bit I think it was Holly Bennett was in charge he allowed not allowed but signed off on the United States to pull all our artillery shells out of a preposition stockpile to give them to the Ukrainians to support them in their ultimately failed counteroffensive

[01:01:32,445]: So when October 7th kicked off and they needed certain types of ammunition the stockpile that we had staged to support Israel in times of crisis was drained and we could not refill it because we were giving the Ukrainians more artillery shells per month than we could produce

[01:01:49,765]: So we were drawing down our stockpiles to very low levels

[01:01:53,285]: Now that’s just artillery

[01:01:54,705]: I don’t at least right now think there’s going to be a lot of artillery battles

[01:02:00,005]: At least I hope not

[01:02:01,005]: If that happens it’s gotten really bad

[01:02:02,745]: But the most precious munition and asset military asset in the world right now is air defense

[01:02:11,405]: So the Ukrainians need Patriot missiles and there’s been a lot of discussion in the press that’s Zelensky’s number one demand when he talks to the United States you want Patriot missiles

[01:02:23,145]: Well the United States is going to need a lot of Patriot missiles to defend our troops in a war with Iran

[01:02:30,125]: So if a war with Iran kicks off and we’re firing through our supply of Patriot missiles we just simply aren’t going to be able to give the Ukrainians anymore

[01:02:37,925]: Sounds like we’re undersupplied

[01:02:40,185]: Absolutely we are

[01:02:41,505]: And this again a lot of this we can talk about ideology all day but at the end of the day this is really a math problem

[01:02:48,645]: We were talking about that earlier with the race that Iran and Iraq are in or excuse me Iran and Israel

[01:02:55,785]: You know it’s our ability to sustain fights like this for long periods of time is extremely limited

[01:03:06,545]: And you’re in a very precarious situation as a result of this

[01:03:11,545]: What do they do with a trillion dollars a year exactly

[01:03:14,525]: That’s a good question

[01:03:15,705]: No for real

[01:03:16,805]: I’m not being mean

[01:03:17,605]: I mean I respect there are some people in the military officers I respect not a ton but some

[01:03:24,105]: I’ve met some really smart ones but like no one thought ahead

[01:03:27,645]: You can’t even produce enough artillery to supply Ukraine and Israel not huge countries like that

[01:03:33,265]: What is that

[01:03:34,385]: So if you look at a system like the Iron Dome in Israel now everybody kind of talks about they call Israel’s entire system the Iron Dome

[01:03:49,545]: It’s really Iron Dome is designed to shoot down cheap rockets from Hamas and Hezbollah

[01:03:56,085]: The systems that are being used now are David’s Sling and the Arrow system and then our THAAD system and some of our naval ships

[01:04:04,805]: But the Iron Dome is designed to be a little more cheap and to shoot more in mass

[01:04:12,695]: We don’t have enough systems similar to that where we can produce a lot of things in mass and in quantity

[01:04:21,095]: We focus on building these expensive systems with a lot of bells and whistles because we still haven’t adapted to the fact that these wars that are quick and cheap and easy or not necessarily cheap but are relatively quick we don’t use a lot of expensive munitions that those are going to be few and far between if not exist in the future

[01:04:44,745]: So our defense industrial base still hasn’t adapted to the fact that we just need to produce more really cheaper and in some cases less advanced weapons in larger scale instead of building these highly advanced weapons with all these bells and whistles in smaller numbers

[01:05:04,085]: Right now again this is public knowledge we only produce about I’d say 100 150 and it could actually be lower interceptors so ammunition for the THAAD system which is our most advanced anti ballistic missile system

[01:05:18,325]: We have only produced around 900 to 1 000 THAAD interceptors

[01:05:25,865]: Just 900 to 1 000

[01:05:27,045]: So total

[01:05:27,445]: I’m not talking launchers I’m talking the rounds for them

[01:05:31,465]: So Iran has about depends on the estimate about 2 000 to 3 000 ballistic missiles that can reach Israel and maybe it’s probably significantly less with Israelis but you see how this quickly becomes a math problem

[01:05:44,925]: We’ve only built between 900 1 000

[01:05:47,585]: They have up to 2 000 types of missiles that the THAAD is designed to shoot down and if you’re assuming 100 success rate you don’t have enough interceptors

[01:05:57,585]: Again I refer to the previous question what do we spend a trillion dollars a year on

[01:06:01,125]: We spend it on those hard to produce expensive systems

[01:06:07,405]: And some of them we have to admit are very capable

[01:06:10,845]: F 35 has gotten a lot of criticism over the years but I think we’ve adapted and turned into a fairly capable system

[01:06:17,105]: Some people may disagree with me on that but I think it is a capable system

[01:06:21,325]: But we haven’t been able to build and that has a lot to do with how we funded it enough of those or enough of certain types of ammunition to really fight a long extended war against an enemy that has either a lot of people or can produce a lot of things like cheap drones or cheap rockets or cheap indirect fire weapons

[01:06:44,245]: We just are not quite set up for that type of fight yet

[01:06:47,205]: Well I mean Russia still occupies Eastern Ukraine

[01:06:50,625]: And for that I mean that is where it should have become patently obvious to us that we have to change how we do this

[01:06:57,825]: And again credit to some of my colleagues at DOD is they know it

[01:07:02,865]: We fortunately just confirmed for Undersecretary of Acquisition and Sustainment Mike Duffy I think Steve Feinberg knows that

[01:07:10,385]: They know but they have a big fight

[01:07:11,745]: They’re going to be fighting a lot of entrenched interests to fix that

[01:07:16,485]: It seems like the wrong time to start swaggering around trying to start new wars with people

[01:07:21,765]: Yeah exactly

[01:07:23,085]: We are trying to fix a lot of things and we’re going to have to put a lot of those things on a back burner if we get into a major regional fight

[01:07:36,905]: If we throw these and I again I don’t know if it’s going to happen but the president’s stated goal is to make sure that Iran doesn’t have nuclear weapons

[01:07:46,925]: I just want to restate you don’t believe as a practical matter that’s achievable with a couple of bunker buster strikes

[01:07:53,765]: I do not

[01:07:55,265]: And again I hope I’m wrong

[01:07:57,025]: I think the best the least worst option is an in person fight

[01:08:01,245]: That’s the perfect diplomatic solution

[01:08:04,185]: That is the best least risky option

[01:08:09,305]: Probably the only option

[01:08:10,465]: I mean you can’t force your wife to love you

[01:08:14,505]: Can’t beat her up until she loves you

[01:08:16,605]: You have to in the end everything is voluntary

[01:08:18,585]: You have to convince people

[01:08:20,345]: And someone who’s well you’re the military guy

[01:08:22,225]: You tell me

[01:08:22,805]: I mean if someone is determined to commit violence against you it’s pretty hard to stop it if he’s still alive right

[01:08:28,345]: You deter it

[01:08:29,425]: And that’s where deterrence comes into effect here is that there are different levers

[01:08:35,845]: And I’ve said this before

[01:08:36,925]: Yes you do need a credible military option for diplomacy to work

[01:08:43,465]: But I think everyone agrees even well not everyone but I think everyone who’s approaching this in a sane manner understands just like with the Ukraine war is that this is the least worst way for this to end is with a robust diplomatic agreement

[01:09:04,065]: Again maybe it’s not so robust

[01:09:05,505]: It’s less than perfect

[01:09:06,525]: That does restrain Iranian nuclear ambitions

[01:09:10,565]: I gotta wonder about the troops who are you know at the barrel end of this thing

[01:09:18,445]: If they read the New York Times they learn that the U S really had nothing to do with any of this

[01:09:23,665]: Just Israel shows up and says we’re doing this

[01:09:26,425]: And now we’re following along and participating to some extent maybe now to a greater extent

[01:09:31,305]: What do they think of that

[01:09:34,525]: It feels like well it doesn’t feel like it’s true

[01:09:36,745]: We were pushed into this by another country

[01:09:39,145]: Is that if you’re serving in uniform away from your family risking death is that like a good reason

[01:09:45,165]: Do you think that’s adequate

[01:09:47,485]: Or do people not think like that when they’re deployed

[01:09:50,485]: I think most folks are going to have those thoughts but they’re going to put them down and they’re going to focus on the mission

[01:09:56,925]: I think that’s what they have to do

[01:09:59,325]: Of course

[01:09:59,585]: I totally agree

[01:10:00,245]: You can’t you know when you’re in the middle of a you know when you’re about to drop bombs on Fordo and you’re a B 2 pilot you can’t in your head be wondering about you know the nature of American foreign policy and how we got here

[01:10:13,165]: No I totally get it

[01:10:15,005]: But when you get home

[01:10:16,845]: Yeah

[01:10:17,365]: And look I have to be honest here

[01:10:20,826]: And I’ve told people this I’m somebody who does believe the United States should have a partnership and support Israel

[01:10:28,106]: I think that an ideal world is that we would have a security architecture where you would have Gulf Arabs cooperating with Israel that would help prevent the rise of a regional hegemon and a global hegemon coming in and dominating the region

[01:10:48,056]: I see benefits to that but I am concerned that if this is perceived as a war for Israel what impact is that going to have on support for us doing some of those things

[01:11:07,066]: And I’ve tried to communicate to people who are strong supporters of the state of Israel that that’s one of these second and third order implications that you need to be aware of is what is going to happen to popular support for the state of Israel

[01:11:18,966]: I think you and Steve Bannon talked about this and there’s another aspect here too

[01:11:26,686]: Right now in the region the Gulf Arab states are wanting to pursue better relations with Israel for a lot of reasons business opportunities other things but one of the biggest things pushing them together is the threat of Iran

[01:11:44,646]: So if Iran collapses it’s a failed state

[01:11:49,466]: If they’re not there I think in a lot of ways again there’s still going to be Iran

[01:11:55,886]: And it’s not clear

[01:11:57,006]: A lot of the regime change advocates can’t articulate really what comes next

[01:12:00,886]: The Shah’s failed son probably is going to go back to Tehran and take over

[01:12:04,186]: These nuts in the MEK aren’t going to come and take over

[01:12:07,286]: But whatever is there if it’s less of a threat if it’s not the same threat again that’s probably good

[01:12:18,406]: But what’s the unintended consequence of that

[01:12:20,906]: Just like the unintended consequence of removing Saddam Hussein was empowering Iran

[01:12:25,286]: If you don’t have that threat posed by Iran anymore that in some ways balances against the Gulf Arabs they’re going to look at Israel and they may have concerns and they may go back to where they were before and be hostile to Israel

[01:12:44,066]: It’s important to remember that for most of the Cold War Israel pursued a foreign policy that was rooted in something called the Periphery Doctrine and it was very smart

[01:12:55,166]: It was driven by Ben Gurion where they dealt with a hostile Arab world particularly the United States that were supported by the Soviets

[01:13:02,446]: So they prioritized building relations with non Arab countries on the periphery of the Middle East

[01:13:08,786]: So primarily Turkey Iran and Ethiopia

[01:13:12,406]: And that was to balance against the Arabs

[01:13:16,326]: And that’s why Israel even after the Islamic Revolution even though Khomeini was screaming death to Israel that’s why initially after Iraq invaded Iran Israel was their main arms supplier and other countries started selling them stuff

[01:13:29,706]: That’s why Israel was such an integral part of Iran Contra why you had a lot of American neoconservatives who were supporters of Israel that were advocates in the 80s people like Michael Ledeen Elliot Abrams of still trying to pursue good relations with Iran even though you had Khomeini shouting death for America death to Israel

[01:13:48,426]: And that’s why up until the end of the Cold War and the defeat of Iraq in the Gulf War that Israel viewed Iraq as a bigger threat as opposed to Iran

[01:14:00,986]: And they were quietly supporting Iran in some cases openly even though you had this very anti Semitic anti Israel regime

[01:14:12,226]: And honestly I believe that was a smart thing to do

[01:14:18,066]: But after the end of the Cold War after Saddam the country they viewed as more threatening was degraded Iran became the bigger threat

[01:14:27,426]: So I tell that story to say is what happens after you don’t have Iran

[01:14:33,766]: Does Turkey become more powerful

[01:14:36,346]: Do other countries start to band together out of fear of what Israel’s done in Iran

[01:14:41,586]: And so I’m really concerned that people aren’t thinking through what could happen here not to mention what could happen in Iran

[01:14:51,386]: I’ve only listened to a small part of your interview with Ted Cruz but he was saying something about how it would be good if the Islamic regime was gone and through a popular uprising

[01:15:01,266]: Yeah in an ideal world you’d have a bunch of Iranian liberals rise up and overthrow the Islamic regime and you’d have a popular democracy in Iran

[01:15:12,866]: But it’s more likely you could have something worse replace the mullahs

[01:15:19,766]: You could have Iran break into a civil war

[01:15:23,446]: You have a lot of ethnic minorities that are looking for independence

[01:15:27,306]: If Iraq hadn’t invaded Iran in 1980 there’s a chance there’s a world where Iran could have devolved into major civil war because of all these ethnic minorities that were trying to break away

[01:15:41,786]: 40 of the country

[01:15:44,146]: So that’s a lot a lot of history there

[01:15:48,726]: But this is what is not being discussed about the risks around regime change that really worries me

[01:15:54,206]: And it’s a repeat of what happened in Iraq in 2003

[01:15:56,386]: Well I think the people pushing it literally just don’t care at all

[01:15:59,366]: And in fact chaos in neighboring states I think it’s bad for the world including Israel

[01:16:06,466]: I think it’s bad for everybody

[01:16:08,046]: But there are some people who think it’s good

[01:16:10,266]: I mean that is a world that is a view

[01:16:13,426]: Abetting chaos on purpose

[01:16:16,166]: Yes

[01:16:16,606]: It’s kind of like so I was just in Europe and was meeting with European diplomats was very interesting

[01:16:23,906]: And some of them were openly saying we want the Ukrainian war to continue because it benefits us

[01:16:31,606]: And these were from countries I won’t you know chat on House rules I won’t say who but these are from countries that were supposedly the strongest supporters of Ukraine saying we want the war to continue

[01:16:42,286]: Not we want Ukraine to win

[01:16:45,046]: We want the war to continue

[01:16:47,026]: Why

[01:16:47,866]: Well for them they perceive Russia as a threat and that if Russia stops fighting in Ukraine then they’ll reorient against them even though there’s really not Putin has not expressed the intent as clearly as some people like to say

[01:17:07,246]: It’s so funny

[01:17:07,726]: I mean if I would just I know the Brits feel this way especially they’ve convinced themselves that Russia is their greatest enemy it’s bizarre

[01:17:17,766]: But you know if I were Putin I would offer free first class trips to Moscow so they could see that like Moscow was so much nicer than any place in Great Britain it’s like not even close

[01:17:29,486]: There’s no part of Great Britain that’s as nice as Moscow it’s like probably an upgrade for them

[01:17:35,346]: I mean their leadership is so bad their country is so degraded

[01:17:39,806]: I think I think a lot of them I think the Brits are starting I will say I think they’re starting to come around a bit

[01:17:47,926]: It’s weird that they’re mad at Putin why aren’t they mad at Keir Starmer

[01:17:51,346]: Why aren’t they mad at the fake conservative Rishi Sunak

[01:17:54,806]: You know what I mean

[01:17:55,906]: I think part of it is for them and I’m not by no means an expert on British politics

[01:18:02,666]: I enjoyed working with some people the British defense establishment was in the Pentagon I have a lot of respect for them but they’re still kind of just grasping at trying to be a global imperial power when they’re you know they don’t have the resources or the power to do that

[01:18:19,946]: Of course and I feel sorry for them sort of but on the other hand it’s like every Western country has the same syndrome where their well deserved frustrations about the decline of their own countries are channeled into hate at people thousands of miles away

[01:18:36,986]: It’s like you’re in a country where people are just dropping dead at 25 of fentanyl ODs like no one can get a job after graduating college and you can’t afford a house and can’t get married or have kids and you’re like I’m mad at Putin I’m mad at the Ayatollahs

[01:18:50,986]: It’s like you know what I mean

[01:18:52,606]: It’s weird kind of like unwillingness to face the truth which is no you’ve been betrayed by your own leaders

[01:18:59,606]: It’s easier to point it’s easier to point abroad than look you know and you’ve seen that throughout history

[01:19:06,366]: You know the British dealt with that in the Falklands War

[01:19:09,386]: Why did Argentina invade the Falklands when they did

[01:19:11,866]: Because the Argentina junta was having severe problems

[01:19:17,146]: And why did Thatcher respond the way that she did

[01:19:19,666]: Because she’d also just come out of these strikes and like that helped her tremendously

[01:19:24,826]: No there’s all kinds of baked in incentives to war

[01:19:27,066]: I just you do wish some of these countries would take that hostility which again is well earned like they have a right to be hostile and focus it against their own leaders and affect regime change in their own countries

[01:19:39,766]: You know these countries they deserve regime change a lot of these countries in the West

[01:19:44,786]: Yeah

[01:19:45,246]: And it’s again for me I’ve been to Ukraine and went to Ukraine last year during the war and I came away with a lot of sympathy and respect for a lot of Ukrainians

[01:19:55,206]: I came away with a lot of immense I’ll just use the word hatred shouldn’t you know let it linger but it was angry at some of the Western supporters of Ukraine and a lot of Ukraine’s leaders

[01:20:10,246]: Tell me why you felt that way

[01:20:12,446]: Because at the end of the day a lot of these people’s strategy is to continue to send young Ukrainians in pursuit of a victory that they know they can’t win

[01:20:24,586]: And they’re doing it just so they can feel good about themselves just so they can say we’re standing up to Putin

[01:20:29,846]: And you know I got to say like you know we haven’t talked about the Ukrainian drone you know issue but last month the ambassador of Ukraine resigned this woman named Bridget Brink and she made a big show of it

[01:20:48,206]: She wrote a op ed for the Detroit Free Press she’s probably going to run for Congress in Michigan

[01:20:55,006]: And it was a bunch of pablum

[01:20:57,766]: It was about you know how America needs to lead the free world how she was essentially ashamed that President Trump’s administration has recognized that the only way Ukraine’s going to survive as a nation is through a diplomatic settlement

[01:21:11,406]: And she was she’s saying that we were betraying our values and all this other nonsense

[01:21:15,846]: She’s a child

[01:21:16,586]: It was childish

[01:21:17,646]: And she was the ambassador of Ukraine

[01:21:19,426]: And I met her actually when I went to Odessa the first time and I interact I was never really directly but on a lot of calls with her when I was in administration

[01:21:29,266]: And she could not articulate how do you achieve some semblance of victory for the Ukrainians considering the fact that they don’t have enough people and we don’t have enough weapons to give them

[01:21:40,906]: She told a friend of mine at an event a cocktail event that her baseline demand was that Putin give back Crimea

[01:21:50,046]: And it’s like she didn’t know what Crimea was

[01:21:52,726]: She didn’t understand

[01:21:54,686]: I mean basically like we’ll have a nuclear war over Crimea is what she but she didn’t even understand that was the implication

[01:21:59,686]: Like she was like an idiot

[01:22:02,166]: Most of the Ukrainian government obviously no government’s a unitary entity but there’s an increasing number of people in the Ukrainian government including some folks that I think a lot of I’m not going to say who they are including some folks that I think would be surprising to people here who recognize reality and they know Crimea is not coming back

[01:22:23,426]: And those people in some ways are becoming the enemies themselves

[01:22:30,546]: And that’s why you see more and more crackdowns on dissent in Ukraine why a lot of people are afraid to speak out and why honestly that major drone attack was launched the day before a negotiating team was going to Istanbul to meet with the Russians

[01:22:49,046]: So what was I mean I don’t the conventional view is there’s no chance the Ukrainians could have pulled that off without the help of NATO

[01:22:59,406]: So again I heard you and Steve Bannon talking about this

[01:23:04,226]: Here’s my view

[01:23:05,806]: I know Steve has been asking a lot about this

[01:23:08,166]: I actually don’t believe that the upper echelons of the Pentagon the CIA the White House State Department knew about this

[01:23:17,286]: Well the White House didn’t know

[01:23:18,726]: I think they’re 100 correct because they would have been incredibly uncomfortable with this happening the day before peace talks

[01:23:27,886]: And I do have to say I think the same applies to CIA leadership

[01:23:30,926]: However I do believe that there were elements of the military supporting Ukraine particularly through training and some of their intelligence sharing and probably elements of the intelligence community that’s supporting Ukraine that knew about this and didn’t run it up the chain because they were worried that they would be told no

[01:23:56,986]: Because they had started this plan under the previous administration and they knew the previous administration likely would have been comfortable with it but ours wouldn’t

[01:24:07,566]: So they probably suppressed that information from getting up the chain

[01:24:11,306]: And I want to be clear I’m not casting aspersions on everybody in European command

[01:24:16,006]: There’s a lot of great officers great soldiers and marine sailors airmen serving European command

[01:24:21,106]: There’s actually some really smart realistic members of the intelligence community that are serving on the Russia Ukraine portfolio

[01:24:29,526]: But there’s others that are still bought in like Bridget Brink to this idea that Ukraine can achieve a victory

[01:24:37,566]: And one way to do it is by these spectacular attacks that while may risk a little thing called nuclear war because we’re attacking Russian strategic assets not just missile launchers and stuff

[01:24:49,586]: And yeah they have a role in the war in Ukraine but remember they also attacked a Russian nuclear submarine base in the north of the country

[01:24:57,906]: So that was done first and foremost to undermine the peace talks

[01:25:02,886]: I think going into Istanbul the day the next day and also to invite some type of escalation

[01:25:09,886]: Well they’ve tried to kill Putin at least twice

[01:25:12,946]: So yeah yeah

[01:25:14,766]: And that leads to one of my last questions second to last question which is why do we put up with that

[01:25:20,606]: I mean if our job is to run the world or at least the West and I think most people in the US government think that is our job maintain the peace act in our interest etc etc

[01:25:32,726]: Zelensky and a few people around him are actively subverting that

[01:25:37,646]: He’s not elected

[01:25:39,526]: He rules by force

[01:25:41,806]: Ukraine is less free than Russia from what I can tell

[01:25:45,766]: Like why are we continuing to send him money

[01:25:48,006]: Why don’t we force him to leave

[01:25:49,566]: Why don’t we I don’t know render him somewhere

[01:25:52,286]: I don’t get it

[01:25:54,166]: I forget was maybe it was you who told me this or you know I have a some British commentator said we’re just really bad at being an empire

[01:26:07,266]: We don’t understand the patron client relationship

[01:26:10,086]: That was me

[01:26:10,906]: I thought that since December of 2003 in Baghdad

[01:26:14,466]: We’re not good at this

[01:26:15,286]: We should things we’re not good at

[01:26:16,466]: Yeah

[01:26:16,606]: We were not built to be an empire

[01:26:18,426]: No the Brits were

[01:26:18,946]: Yeah

[01:26:19,826]: The Brits definitely were

[01:26:21,446]: But we are not you know we were meant to be a republic not an empire

[01:26:26,946]: And I think we I will say this administration has started to change that

[01:26:32,606]: I can’t tell you how much the aid pause that we did really freaked out the establishment and sent an important message to Ukrainians but also the Europeans

[01:26:42,566]: But there’s still a ways to go

[01:26:44,206]: I think we need to really change that mental model about how partners and allies we work with partners and allies

[01:26:54,826]: It doesn’t mean that we are telling them what to you know we’re dominating them in certain ways

[01:27:00,586]: We’re always trying to throw them under the bus

[01:27:02,286]: That doesn’t work either

[01:27:04,326]: But this idea that we let certain clients do things constantly that are against our interest it doesn’t benefit us in the long term

[01:27:13,886]: It doesn’t benefit these clients

[01:27:15,766]: I mean look at what happened in Afghanistan

[01:27:17,886]: I think that’s a perfect example of that

[01:27:20,446]: Last question

[01:27:24,086]: If you had to bet do you think the U S government is capable of closing out this war in Iran

[01:27:37,546]: Like saying to Israel you know we’ve done enough like stop

[01:27:43,926]: And if Donald Trump decides you know he wanted to go back to the negotiating table send Steve Whitkoff to Oman again to meet with the Iranians and try and hammer something out

[01:27:52,986]: Do we have the power to do that

[01:27:55,606]: I think it’s this is an interesting question

[01:27:58,446]: Are we talking about capability or willingness

[01:28:01,226]: Both

[01:28:02,006]: Like could that actually happen

[01:28:03,606]: Is that realistic

[01:28:04,946]: I think that is entirely possible

[01:28:08,406]: I say it’s likely

[01:28:09,286]: I don’t know

[01:28:10,446]: Yeah we can’t know

[01:28:11,086]: But you think it’s possible

[01:28:12,406]: Of course

[01:28:13,026]: I mean we have done this before

[01:28:16,966]: I mean I think you know with Israel specifically you know Ronald Reagan is considered a very pro Israel president

[01:28:26,986]: He was a very pro Israel president for sure

[01:28:29,126]: But there were times where where the feeling was is that Israel was not doing things in our interest

[01:28:34,546]: And we made that clear

[01:28:35,866]: And we used our leverage to make sure that they were not harming American interests

[01:28:43,426]: And I think we perfectly have the capability to do that

[01:28:52,286]: Again I I we don’t know how the next few days are going to play out but it’s it’s definitely there

[01:29:00,126]: Is we have a tremendous amount of leverage over many parties in the Middle East over you know many countries around the world

[01:29:07,666]: We just have used it incredibly poorly

[01:29:12,646]: Dan Kogel I keep reading about what an extremist you are

[01:29:14,706]: I think you’re the most moderate person I’ve spoken to this month

[01:29:19,026]: Who else are you interviewing

[01:29:21,846]: Thank you

[01:29:22,606]: Is Jelani coming

[01:29:23,806]: Do you have

[01:29:24,906]: Are you going to Damascus

[01:29:25,326]: No no we love Jelani

[01:29:26,546]: We’re totally pro ISIS now

[01:29:28,466]: It’s totally cool

[01:29:29,506]: Are you going to Damascus

[01:29:30,526]: As long as Assad is gone

[01:29:32,046]: The funny thing is I was invited by by Assad a couple of times and I didn’t go both because you know I didn’t have super strong feelings about it

[01:29:42,546]: I was like that’s not worth it

[01:29:44,046]: You know it’s just not I’ve got other interests and I’m not I don’t want to spend my life thinking about the Middle East

[01:29:48,806]: But if I’d gone I think that would have been I mean it kind of wrecked Tulsi Gabbard’s life for a number of years got her kicked out of the Democratic Party

[01:29:55,646]: But if you were to go to Damascus with Jelani the former Daesh guy the ISIS guy Al Qaeda guy true extremist totally cool

[01:30:06,106]: I mean al Nusra I mean al Nusra and ISIS split but yeah he was a member of ISIS

[01:30:11,406]: I’m using the terms broadly but like radical Sunni extremist like nihilist

[01:30:17,286]: We do have to say one thing though about you brought up Tulsi Gabbard is there’s a lot of good staff right now in the administration that are doing the Lord’s work

[01:30:27,566]: And I have to say some of the things that are being said about them and how they’re being undermined in the press and being accused of awful things is absolutely disgusting

[01:30:38,706]: Their candidly is an effort to run somewhat of the same playbook against them they did me

[01:30:44,306]: It’s like you’re seeing these accusations of leaking and they’re on the outs

[01:30:48,026]: Let’s be honest

[01:30:49,066]: That’s a trick that people who want a bigger war are playing to stifle dissent

[01:30:54,966]: Oh I’m aware

[01:30:56,006]: Because if you dissent you know look as I said before you dissent and they make a decision to do something

[01:31:03,586]: It’s your job to implement it

[01:31:05,766]: But they’re trying to snuff out any sort of process or debate right now by attacking and trying to accuse certain groups of people whether it’s in the White House the Pentagon ODNI State Department of leaking

[01:31:19,446]: So they’re scaring them away from actually offering feedback and challenge

[01:31:24,586]: And that’s utterly disgusting

[01:31:26,766]: And you know I know that there’s a lot of good people in the White House that aren’t going to tolerate it

[01:31:31,966]: They’re not going to be bullied by it

[01:31:37,826]: But I think we acknowledge it’s happening

[01:31:39,906]: And it’s not surprising but it still is utterly fucking disgusting

[01:31:43,666]: Can I say one thing and you’re definitely in this category but it’s the people who’ve been targeted in general are the most patriotic the most pro American the most people whose views are the most consistent with the ones Donald Trump ran on

[01:31:58,606]: I have noticed that

[01:31:59,586]: I think it’s true for you

[01:32:00,306]: It’s certainly true for Tulsi

[01:32:01,206]: And they’re also the people that when the president says we’re doing this they’re going to implement it

[01:32:07,686]: And if they don’t agree with it if it goes against their core beliefs so much then they’re going to resign

[01:32:14,146]: They’re not going to do what Jim Jeffery who we were talking about earlier is going to do

[01:32:18,426]: They’re not going to do what people in the first term did and undermine it

[01:32:21,286]: They’re going to say Roger that and go forward

[01:32:26,626]: And that’s what makes this whole thing even worse

[01:32:29,066]: Yeah they’re attacking the best people because lying is not a crime

[01:32:32,486]: Telling the truth is

[01:32:34,206]: Yeah

[01:32:34,706]: Thank you Dan

[01:32:35,726]: Thank you

[01:32:36,426]: Don’t grab me again

[01:32:40,866]: So it turns out that YouTube is suppressing this show

[01:32:44,526]: On one level that’s not surprising

[01:32:46,186]: That’s what they do

[01:32:46,866]: But on another level it’s shocking

[01:32:48,406]: With everything that’s going on in the world right now all the change taking place in our economy and our politics with the wars we’re on the cusp of fighting right now Google has decided you should have less information rather than more

[01:33:01,146]: And that is totally wrong

[01:33:03,506]: It’s immoral

[01:33:04,506]: What can you do about it

[01:33:06,286]: Well we could whine about it

[01:33:07,806]: That’s a waste of time

[01:33:08,966]: We’re not in charge of Google

[01:33:09,926]: Or we could find a way around it a way that you could actually get information that is true not intentionally deceptive

[01:33:15,986]: The way to do that on YouTube we think is to subscribe to our channel

[01:33:20,006]: Subscribe

[01:33:20,546]: Hit the little bell icon to be notified when we upload and share this video

[01:33:24,846]: That way you’ll have a much higher chance of hearing actual news and information

[01:33:30,406]: So we hope that you’ll do that

---

---

Transcribe your media with TRNSCRB.
Transcribe multiple languages, effortlessly. Chat with your projects. Enhance your workflow.